Sunday, November 21, 2021

China Since the 1949 Revolution

 Introductory Remarks

  • Since the communists took power China may be divided into two main phases:
  • a)a revolutionary phase, which lasted until the death f Mao Zedong in 1976.
  • b) a pragmatic phase, which extended to the death of Deng Xiaoping in 1997.

  • In the first phase Mao Zedong attempted to put the revolutionary commitment into practice.
  • This led to a sequences of policies referred to as
  • a) the Soviet period 1952-8.
  • b) Great Leap Forward & its aftermath - 1958-65
  • c) the Cultural Revolution from 1966 to Mao's death decade later.

  • These divisions obscure major continuities throughout the period
  • But they do not provide a convenient framework within which to examine developments.


The Period of Consolidation

  • Until 1952 the main effort of the new government was expended on consolidating its control.
  • No resistance remained in China Proper after the Guomindang's departure from the mainland.
  • There was a real danger of subversion and to guard against this.
  • In September 1949 the country was divided into
  • a) 6 military region much remained
  • b) a joint military and administrative commissions.

  • The CCP referred to the border regions as the "old liberated areas" and
  • The rest of China was called the "new liberated areas."
  • In toehold liberated areas the Communist leadership was already established
  • In the new areas much remained to be done.
  • Guangzhou was not occupied until 2 weeks after the establishment of the PRC.
  • In the new liberated areas most senior Guomindang
  • The first task was to find people with skill and political reliability to take over their posts.
  • The task was also to keep essential services functioning.
  • In this the student body played an important role.
  • Four tasks needed to be addressed immediately.

  • 1) the first was to define the political characteristics of the new state.

  • In September 1949, a People's Political Consultative conference was convened.
  • An Organic Law and Common Programme were adopted.
  • The former established a "democratic dictatorship" led by the CCP.

  • The Organic Law & Common Programme guaranteed
  • a) basic human rights
  • b) equality for women.
  • c) the continuation of revolutionary land reform
  • d) the development of heavy industry
  • e) safeguards of the rights of minority people.

  • 2) the second task  was to gain control of the economy which meant curbing inflation.

  • This was achieved by increasing government revenue
  • They did this by creating a unified fiscal system and by selling bonds
  • Various strategies were employed to keep government expenditure under control.
  • 3) the new government was intent on asserting control over all territory deemed to be part of China.

  • The three provinces of Manchuria were now fully integrated into China.
  • Tibet, autonomous since 1913 was "liberated" by the People's Liberation Army in 1950.
  • It later became the Xiang Autonomous Region.
  • Outer Mongolia had become the Mongolian People's Reut failedpublic in 1924.
  • It remained independent.
  • In Oct. 1949, a Communist force tried but failed to seize the island of Jinmen (Quemoy)
  • Their rebuttalff showed that an invasion of Taiwan would be a major operation.
  • The matter was postponed.

  • 4) the fourth priority task concerned foreign relations.

  • During World War II China had treated flatteringly by the United States as a great power
  • In the post-war period and the civil war, China's international status had declined.
  • It had declined to that of a client state.

  • The CCP aspired to present China as an independent and unaligned power.
  • In 1949, in the atmosphere of the Cold War, it seemed that China must "lean to one side."
  • This meant seeking an alliance with the Soviet Union.

  • In Dec. 1949 Mao Zedong left China for the first time in his life.
  • He went to Moscow to negotiate with Stalin.
  • There was a show of cordiality between the two.
  • But neither man fully trusted the other.
  • The negotiation were difficult and prolonged.s most important
  • The outcome was thew Sino-Soviet Treaty of Alliance and Mutual Assistance.
  • Its most important provisions were a promise of mutual support.
  • This would be in the advent of an attack by Japan.
  • The provision also included a soviet advance of $300 million in credits to China.
  • The implications of the alliance with the Soviet Union soon became apparent.
  • In June 1950, a civil war broke out between North and South Korea.
  • After the North Korean troops had overrun the south, the United Nations sent forces.
  • This was to assist South Korea.
  • At the same time the United States interposed its Seventh Fleet in the Taiwan Straits.
  • This was to prevent China using the opportunity to invade the island.
  • By Nov. 1950, the United Nations' forces had invaded North Korea.
  • They were also within  50 miles of the Yalu River, the frontier with China.
  • At that point China intervene on a massive scale.They drove the United Nations' forces back to the 38th parallel.
  • This was the boundary between the North and South of Korea.
  • The war then stalemated and a truce was signed in June 1953.

  • China intervened in the war because of the collapse of the North Korean army.
  • Also China felt the threat of a United Nations force, in effect a United States force.
  • This was because it was becoming poised on its north east frontier.d

  • China's participation in the war was significant in a variety of ways:
  • a) the Chinese forces, led by Peng Dehuai, achieved remarkable success.
  • b) the war exposed serious military weaknesses.
  • c) a decision was taken to modernize the PLA and to develop the Air Force.

  • The war cost over 700,000  Chinese casualties, among them Mao Zedong's son and China insured very heavy debts to the Soviet Union for the purchase of arms.
  • China's involvement also deepened the rift with the United States.
  • The USA now became committed to the support of theNationalists on Taiwan
  • In China, the threat of war was used to whip up support for the regime.
  • This was done through the "ResistAmerica, Aid Korea" campaign.
  • It was used to justify a hard line against people suspected of not supporting the regime.

  • During these years the programme of revolutionary land reform wags completed.
  • The Agrarian Reform Land Law of 1950 extended land reform to the new liberated areas.
  • Its purpose was to end the feudal exploitation  of the landlord class.
  • It was also to preserve a rich peasant economy.
  • This was to enable the revival of agricultural production.
  • Land reform had been completed by 1952 except in areas occupied by national minorities.
  • These were exempted.
  • Then about 43% of China's cultivated land had been confiscated and redistributed.
  • About 60% of the rural population benefitted from this.
  • Many poor peasants who owned littler no land had survived by selling their labour.
  • They now became middle peasants.
  • but the reform was achieved at a high cost.
  • The importance of this measure was to consolidate peasant support behind the regime.
  • The number of landlords and rural power holders who died ranged from 200,000 to 2 million.

  • The redistribution on average gave a poor peasant just over a quarter of an acre of land.
  • This did little to solve the problem of land shortage.
  • Between 1949 and 1952 output rose by 12.6%.
  • This may reflect the post war recovery.
  • It may reflect  greater effort from peasants.
  • They did not have to surrender much of their crop to landlords.
  • The rise in output could not be sustained - it needed more measures.
  • During these years several other measures helped to consolidate the CCP position.

  • In 1950 a Marriage Law was introduced.
  • This replaced the feudal marriage system with the New Democratic marriage system.
  • a) women were allowed to freely choose their partner
  • b) women were given equal rights relating to divorce.
  • c) they were given custody of children & property.

  • After the law had been passed, women's associations led to a mass campaign.lize 
  • This was to publicize the changes.
  • Then divorces increased dramatically.
  • But in rural areas many features of the traditional marriage continued.
  • Steps were taken immediately to increase education opportunities.
  • Those whose schooling had been interrupted by the war wee offered accelerated programmes,
  • Millions of adults attended winter study classes & spare timer schooling.

  • Teachers were re-educated
  • School texts were revised.
  • Political  study classes were held.
  • Missionary educators left the country.
  • Their schools and universities were nationalized.
  • By 1952 62% of children wee in primary school
  • increases in high school and universities were impressive.
  • The new government  needed to gain the confidence of businesses & industries 
  • Economic activity in the cities were at a standstill.at the end of the civil war.
  • Public utilities were out of commission.
  • The Traditional sector of the economy wold not be reformed.
  • Strikes were discouraged by the government
  • They encouraged the negotiations of modest salary claims.

  • The modern economic sector was immediately affected by
  • a) the departure of most foreigners
  • b) the departure of Chinese industrialists who had close links with the Guomindang.

  • Their enterprises were taken over by the state,

  • Three major campaigns were initiated
  • a)against suspected counter-revolutionaries
  • b) against corrupt cadres
  • c) against capitalists in the Five Antis campaign

  • The campaign against counter-revolutionaries began with
  • a) mass rallies
  • b) denunciations

  • This was followed by arrests and executions
  • In the Guangzhou region alone more than 28,000 people were executed.
  • In the country as many as 500,000 to 800, 000 people may have been killed.

  • The campaig against corrupt cadres originated with a shortage of them.
  • This was when the CCP came to power.
  • Recruiting cadres who were not satisfactory in class or commitment.
  • 10% of party cadres were weeded out.

  • The Five Antis campaign was attack on the wealthy capitalists.
  • It was claimed that they were defrauding the public through various crimes.
  • Capitalists who were found guilty were forced to pay heavy fines.
  • They were made to accept state control of their enterprises.
  • Mass campaigns mobilized the population.

The Soviet Period: 1953-8.

  • In 1953 the Communist leaders began to implement its policy.
  • It was the policy of socialist transformation & economic development
  • This meant
  • a) the transfer of ownership from private to public hands
  • b) the introduction of centralized economic planning.er

  • In September the First Five Year Plan was introduced.
  • So the collectivization of agriculture began.

  • The influence of Soviet Russia on China was already apparent in a variety of forms.
  • With the adoption of state planning the Chinese debt to Russia was noticeable.
  • They selected a developmental model which gave priority to heavy industry.
  • This meant large scale, capital intensive & technically advanced plants.
  • This assumed the institutionalized transformation of the agricultural sector.
  • This was to supply much of the capital needed.
  • In this way china was following the path recommended by Lenin and implemented by Stalin.

  • China seemed to be so dependent on a foreign power.contribute
  • Only the Soviet Union was willing to this heavy industry.
  • The Chinese leadership believed that this was an essential element in its transition to socialism.

  • China now received soviet assistance in the form of
  • a) advice
  • b) extensive economic aid
  • c) the introduction of soviet method

  • At first 156 major industrial enterprises were supplied
  • This included 7 iron & steel  plants, 245 power stations & 63 machinery plants.
  • Many were in kit form to be assembled In China.
  • Later another 125 projects were approved.
  • Then 11,000 Soviet specialists were sent to China.
  • They were to supervise the installation & operation of plants.
  • They would also provide technical assistance.
  • 28,000 Chinese students were sent to Russia to study.
  • The period of the First Five Year Plan saw a number of other important initiatives.
  • Most of China's modern industry was concentrated in the coastal cities & the north east.

  • Industrial complexes were sited in the interior.
  • Major steel complexes were constructed at Wuhan & Inner Mongolia.
  • An oil refinery was built at Lanzhou in Gansu.
  • To service these plants a large investment was made in new railways.
  • This included a line constructed from Xi'an to Xinjiang oil-fields.
  • The Soviet model of "one-management" was introduced.
  • This replaced the management committee & worker representation of China.
  • Workers in the Yan'an period had responded to ideological incentives, now they did piecework.
  • Or, they were graded on salary scales.
  • The soviet influence was also apparent in education, especially in colleges & universities.
  • They were reorganized on Soviet line.
  • Russian academic advisers assisted in the planning of courses.
  • Russian textbooks were widely used.
  • Expenditure on higher education tripled between 1952 and 1957.
  • The number of students, a third of them studied engineering & it rose quickly. 
  • Students from poor families received free tuition & maintenance grants.
  • in return the students had to maintain the 8:1:50 schedule.
  • Eight hours of sleep, 1 hour of exercise, & 50 hours of work.

  • The socialist transformation of society also implied the collectivization of agriculture.
  • The arguments of this step were both economic and political.
  • Revolutionary land reform led to greater fragmentation of agricultural holdings
  • Peasants farming small, scattered holding could not accumulate capital for investments.
  • They could not maintain the sustained rise in output & productivity.
  • This was needed to feed the growing population and release surplus labour for industry.

  • The Soviet Union had collectivized agriculture in  the 1930s.
  • It was capital that came from the agricultural sector which provided investment in industry.
  • Since land reform poor peasant had to sell their land they had been given.
  • In 1955 Mao complained of the capitalist element in the rural  areas.

  • In the Yan'an period co-operatives had been encouraged - this was mutual  aid team

  • They had pooled their resources & from 1954 they were encouraged to amalgamate
  • This was to form agricultural producers' co-operatives
  • In these families got to retain their land; they were farmed co-operatively.
  • Crops were divided according to the amount of land & labour was supplied by each family

  • .China's rich peasants were not as numerous as the kulaks.
  • Nor were they as established.
  • Collectivization  in China was better timed.
  • It was only a short period that had elapsed since land reform.
  • The capitalist tendencies in the countryside had not become firmly established.
  • Collectivization appealed. to the rational self-interest of peasants.
  • It was carried through by local cadres who had a clear grasp of the situation.
  • On July 31st 1955 Mao Zedong called for a sharp increase in the rate of collectivization.
  • In the winter of 1955-56 co-operative began to be merged into Advanced Producers' Co-operatives.
  • These were  collective farms
  • This is where private ownership was abolished.
  • Members were renumerated on the basis of their labour.
  • By the end of1956 the socialist  transformation of agriculture was virtually completed.

  • China's collectivizing agriculture was compared favourably with the Soviet Union.
  • But there it was opposed by rich peasants or kulaks - several million lost their lives.

The Great Leap Forward & the Sino-Soviet Split

  • In 1958 China embarked on a radical, Evan utopian programme.
  • This was to complete the building of socialism ahead of time.
  • It was meant to carry out the gradual transition to communism.

  • Behind this rapid change & direction lay a complex set of interactions within
  • a) the Party
  • b) the economy
  • c) industrial management
  • d) educational strategy.
  • e) international relations.

  • One indication of the strain imposed by change was the disillusionment of the intellectuals.
  • These were the educational elites.
  • Most of them had welcomed the Communist victory in 1949
  • At first the CCP had tolerated what was seen as the intellectual bourgeoisie individualism.
  • In 1955 a harder line was adopted.
  • A mass campaign was launched against the poet Hu Feng.
  • He had criticized the Party's insistence that culture should be proletarian.
  • The campaign was used to warn intellectuals not to oppose the first five Year Plan
  • They were also not to oppose the collectivization of agriculture.


The Hundred Flowers Movement

  • In 1956 Zhou Enlai commented that the Party needed the support of the intellectuals.
  • They were needed to promote the economy & to reform the bureaucracy.
  • In May, Mao Zedong was engaged in a Party debate over the pace of co-operatization.
  • He  announced "Let a hundred flowers bloom, a hundred schools of thought contend."
  • After some hesitation intellectuals began to criticize the competence of cadres.

  • Mao heard of the Hungerian uprising of November 1956 & offered a reason for its cause.
  • It was the isolation of the Hungarian Communist Parry from the masses & the intellectuals.

  • In Feb.1957 Mao gave a speech
  • It was entitled "On the Correct Handling of Contradictions Among the People."
  • He argued that "non-antagonistic contradictions" could exist in a communist society.
  • He also said that their resolution by discussion would speed up progress to socialism.

  • He encouraged intellectuals to believe that open expression of opinions would be welcomed.
  • Many articles critical of the Party, of educational policies were published.
  • These articles even criticized Mao Zedong as well.

  • Students from Beijing University began to put up posters.
  • These posters were criticizing officials on the"democracy wall"
  • This was a stretch of wall near the Forbidden City.

  • In June the CCP counter-attacked with an anti-Rightist campaign,
  • The most outspoken critics of the Hundred flowers Movement were singled out.
  • They were singled out to be punished.
  • Other intellectuals were forced to participate in their denunciations.

  • One of the most famous victims was the writer Deng Lin.
  • She was accused of having opposed the Party leadership inher literary work.
  • She refused to admit her faults.
  • She was sent to redeem herself through labour on a farm near the Soviet border.

  • There First Five Year Plan, as an economic strategy had serious shortcomings
  • Investment  had been concentrated on heavy industry.
  • It had grown at the rate five times faster than that of agriculture.
  • The increase in agricultural output had done little more than feed the growing population.

  • The industrial sector had grown.
  • But it had not  created the large numbers of jobs needed traduce unemployment in the cities.
  • more jobs would be created if the consumer industries were expanded.
  • But they were restricted by shortages of raw material.

  • Mao gave a speech entitled "On the Ten Great Relationships" given in 1956.
  • He had expounded a theory of relationships.
  • He defined it as "contradictions" in economic development.
  • The first was between industry & agriculture and between heavy industry and light industry.

  • He admitted that heavy industry must continue to be given priority.
  • his conclusion was that agriculture & light industry must also be developed.
  • This was a strategy which came to be called "walking on two legs."

  • Other dissatisfactions included a reaction against the one-man management system.
  • This system had been associated with Gao Gang
  • He was the chairman f the State Planning Commission.
  • In 1954, he had been accused  of plotting against Liu Shaoqi and had committed suicide.

  • At the 8th Party Congress (Sept. 1956) the "one-man management system was criticized.
  • It was replaced by a system of collective leadership with the Party in command.

  • The extensive Russian influence on education was also challenged. 
  • From 1956 attampts were made to speed up the expansion of education.
  • Relations with the Soviet Union had improved after Stalin's death in 1953.

  • When Khrushchev & Bulganin visited China in 1954 and thengs had appeared OK.
  • It seemed the two countries had achieved a relationship of equality and mutual respect
  • But in Feb.1956 Krushchev delivered his secret speech denouncing Stalin.
  • Mao Zedong resented Khrushchev's failure to give him warning of the speech.
  • Mao believed the speech was liable to cause dissension in the Communist world.
  • This was a time when unity was essential.

  • Disagreement on the issue exposed ideological differences.
  • This was true over the inevitability of war with capitalist powers.
  • Khrushchev denied this
  • The attack on Stalin's personality cult may may have also caused Mao to be concerned.
  • This was about his own posthumous reputation.
  • Despite these differences, Mao Zedong visited Moscow for the second time.
  • This was in Nov.1957, soon after the Soviet Union had launched Sputnik.
  • This event led Mao to praise the achievements of theSoviet Union.
  • He also declared that "The East Wind is prevailing over the Western Wind."
  • In late 1957, a Second Five-Year Plan was being considered.
  • Indications began to multiply that something was about to change.
  • The conservative economic strategy was about to be replaced by a radical programme.
  • In the countryside a massive programme of irrigation was rushed through.
  • It used the labour of 100 million peasants.
  • In November the People's Daily gave prominence to the slogan"More, better, faster, cheaper."
  • Mao gave speech at the Supreme State conference on January 28, 1958.
  • Mao declared that "it is possible to catch up with Britain in 15 years."
  • Shortly afterward production targets for both agriculture and industry were raised.
  • This was done in dramatic form.
  • In the same speech Mao declared "In making revolution ne must strike while the iron is hot - one revolution must follow another, the revolution must continually advance."
  • This was his theory of a "permanent revolution."
  • It was a process that embraced both the economic and the social superstructure of society.
  • The Great Leap Forward would soon follow.
  • It is connected with Mao's concept of revolutionary change.
  • In April 1958, 27 Advanced Producers' Co-operatives in Henan decided to amalgamate.
  • They formed a commune.
  • this was without formal direction from the centre.

  • Other co-operatives followed suit.
  • in August  communes received official approval.
  • Before the end of the year the 700,000 Agricultural Producers' Co-operatives had been re-organized.
  • They were organized into 24,000 People's  Communes.
  • Each had an average of 5000 families.
  • In the autumn, communes were also organized into urban areas.
  • The model for these was the Zhengzhou Spinning and Weaving Machine Plant commune.
  • This was in Henan, which was centred on the factory but which also farmed some land.
  • The economic benefit for this was the mobilization of labour.
  • This was for large scaled labour intensive projects.
  • To maximize the release of labour, the private plots were abolished.
  • Peasants had been allowed to keep these plots in the Agricultural Producers' Co-operatives.
  • Rural markets ceased to function.
  • To enable women to participate in productive labour, creates and nurseries were introduced.
  • Collective kitchens were also organized and a free food system was introduced.
  • The labour thus made available was employed on major construction projects.
  • One such projects was the Mng Tombs Dam near Beijing.
  • The  labour force was also used to develop rural industry,.
  • There were reports of an abundant harvest.
  • So communes were encouraged to prospect for local sources of iron ore.
  • They were encouraged to construct their own "backyard steel furnaces."

  • During the Great Leap Forward , vastly-increased targets were set for industrial production.
  • The target for steel output was fixed in Feb.1958 at 6.2 million metric tons.
  • This was already a 19% increase on the previous year's production.
  • In August , Mao endorsed raising it to 10.7 million tons.
  • A few weeks later he even suggested the figure of 12million tons.
  • To achieve such targets over a range of industries hundreds of state projects were started.
  • Between 1957 & 1960 the number of people employed in state industries doubled.
  • It reached over 50 million.
  • This placed an immense strain on the system of food procurement from the countryside.
  • This vast workforce was encouraged by ideological exhortation to work excessively long hours.
  • There were no plants which were over-used and under-maintained.

  • The Gereat Leap Forward was more than a leap of economic growth.
  • In Sept. 1958 a "great leap" in education was announced. 
  • This was partly a matter of rapidly expanding educational opportunity.
  • This was especially true in the country-side.
  • Primary school enrolment rose by 20 million.
  • There were large increases in  the number of students at secondary & tertiary level.
  • Some 30,000 agricultural middle schools & 400 "red & expert" universities were opened.
  • At the same time important changes took place in the operation of the educational system.
  • The new schools were run on the minban or run-by-the-people principle.
  • Productive labour was intro the curriculum in all schools and at all levels.
  • Students were encouraged to voice their criticism of teachers.
  • Another feature of the communes was
  • a) the revival of the people's militia
  • b) the arming of the peasantry
  • The need  for military preparedness was justified by the crisis of August 1958
  • This had been caused by the declaration that China intended to "liberate" Taiwan.

  • It was also a challenge to the professional leadership of the People's Liberation Army.
  • It was a reminder of the "people's war" fought in the Yan'an days.
  • The communes also briefly  offered women an escape.
  • This was an escape from the double burden of domesticality & work.
  • This embrace in urban communes.
  • This is where women, who in the past had been restricted to the home, took a leading role.
  • Their main leadership role was organizing child-minding arrangements.
  • Other features of the commune was the break from the traditional family structure.
  • The joy of the Great Leap Forward  in 1958 was followed by disillusionment and dissension.
  • In the next year it had become apparent that reports of a bumper harvest had been exaggerated.
  • They also realized  the industrial targets which had been set were unrealistic.
  • An early response to this realization was to reorganize the communes.
  • The made the production brigade.
  • communal eating  was ended.
  • Steps were taken to restore private plots and to reopen rural markets.

  • A retreat from  the Great Leap Forward began.
  • The political conflict, which had had simmered under the surface since 1956, had come out in the open.
  • The Party's  Central Committee  meeting took place in Wuhan in Dec. 1958.
  • It was there that Mao agreed to step down as Chairman of the People's Republic.
  • Mao retained the chairmanship of the Party.
  • He later claimed that after the Wuhan meeting he was treated like a "dead ancestor."
  • In July at a conference in Lushan, Mao received a letter from Peng Dehuai.
  • Peng was a veteran of the Long March who was now minister of defence.
  • He warned Mao that the achievements of the Great Leap Forward were being exaggerated.

  • Maio chose to publish the letter and to attack Peng Dehuai openly at the conference.
  • Peng had recently returned from Moscow.
  • Mao accused him of having conspired with Krushchev to criticize the communes.
  • He also accused him of conspiring to cancel the offer of nuclear aid for China.
  • Subsequently Peng Dehuai was replaced at the Ministry of Defence by Lin Biao.
  • Lin Biao was a close supporter of Mao.
  • Critics of the Great Leap Forward were intimidated.
  • A second Great Leap began in 1960.
  • A feature of the Second Great Leap was the intensive introduction of urban communes.
  • This was an attempt to make urban areas more self-sufficient.
  • The sEcond Great Leap Forward  was finally abandoned (by mid-1961) due to a number of factors.
  • a) mistaken agricultural policies.
  • b) bad weather
  • c) the withdrawal  of Soviet technicians in July had, by mid-1961 forced the abandonment of the Second Great Leap.
  • The Great Leap Forward had a disastrous effect on China's population.
  • There was a decline in food production.
  • The breakdown in the system of distribution had set off a famine.
  • The cumulative increase in mortality is estimated as between 16 & 27 million deaths
  • The famine, which at its height in 1960 was felt more severely in rural areas.
  • It was more sever in certain provinces.
  • Anhui alone suffered about 2 million deaths.
  • These figures may be compared with the loss of life in the Soviet Union.
  • This would be at the time of the collectivization of agriculture
  • Here the estimates  suggests 5 million deaths.
  • The Party's response to this tragedy was very inadequate.
  • This was because of a lack of accurate information.
  • The system of gathering statistics had collapsed.
  • It had been replaced by grossly exaggerated claims of increases in output.
  • Partly it was because many Party leaders remained silent.
  • The consequences played a significant role in deepening the Sino-Soviet dispute.
  • The origins of the dispute may be traced back to
  • a) several incidents in the history of the rise of the CCP
  • b) the negotiations of the Treaty of Alliance & Mutual Assistance in 1950.
  • c) the Sino-Soviet relations during the Korean War
  • d) Krushchev's secret speech denouncing Stalin in 1956.
  • e) the tensions which had emerged during Mao's visit to the Soviet Union in Nov.1957.
  • It was the Great Leap Forward which brought these tensions out in the open.
  • A number of factors threatened to deprive the Soviet Union of making ideological claims:
  • a) the rejection of Soviet economic methods,
  • b) the trumpeting of the initial achievements of the Great Leap Forward 
  • c) the hailing of the communes as a short cut to communism.

  • The Soviets wanted to lay claim to the "ideological and economic leader of the socialist  camp."

  • The tensions  were heightened in 1958 & 1959.
  • This was caused by  various international crises.
  • The first one started with the United States  landing in Lebanon
  • On that day Krushchev arrived in Beijing, his response to this crisis was criticized..
  • It was criticized in the Red Flag, the Party's journal.

  • Soon after, the Chinese threat to "liberate" Taiwan was treated cooly by the Soviet Union
  • Two events  were to pose a threat to China:
  • a) the Tibetan revolt in the spring of 1959.
  • b) the flight of the Dalai Lama
  • The Soviet Union did not offer firm support.

  • The break between both countries followed shortly after.
  • In June 1959 the Soviet Union rescinded the offer of nuclear assistance.
  • It was an offer that they made two tears previously.
  • At the same time, Mao heard about the reports of critical remarks made by Krushchev
  • These remarks were about the communes.
  • In April 1960 there'd Flag openly criticized theSoviet Union's policy of peaceful co-existence.
  • Wth this, and its rejection of China's economic policies the break between them was set.
  • This led the soviet Union to announce that its technicians would be withdrawn in two months.
  • The diplomatic estrangement was to last until 1985.

Prelude to the Cultural Revolution

  • The years, following the disaster of the Great Leap Forward, was dominated by two things:
  • a) economic reconstruction
  • b) educational & political adjustments.
  • Steps were taken to restore the agrarian economy
  • In 1959 the brigade  had replaced the commune as the unit of accounting.
  • Private plots had been restored
  • Up to 30 million people were relocated from the cities to the countryside.
  • A large reduction in cereal procurement followed from that.

  • Under Chen Yun's direction an "agricultural first" economic strategy was developed.
  • He believed that the mobilization  of labour alone could not solve China's problems.
  • This was agricultural problems.
  • Chen did a few things.
  • a) he increased state investments in agriculture,
  • b) he expanded the production of agriculture machinery & fertilizers.
  • c) he developed a" high and stable yield" area policy.

  • This encouraged regions to concentrate on expanding cereal production.
  • In the industrial sector many state enterprises were closed down.
  • A partial return was made to the one-man management practices of the First Five Year Plan.
  • As a result by 1965 agricultural output had returned to the level achieved in 1957.
  • In the meantime the population had risen by 80 million.

  • Industrial output recovered even more quickly.
  • By 1963 a period of sustained growth had begun.
  • This growth was aided by th development of new industries
  • One such industry was the petrochemical industry.

  • The recovery was remarkable  for two reasons: it was achieved a time when
  • a) China was technologically isolated.
  • b) when the development of nuclear weapons was absorbing high technology sources - China's first nuclear test took place in October 1964.

  • In education the principle of "walking on two legs" was not abandoned.
  • But it was modified extensively.

  • The number of pupils in elementary schools fell from 93 million in 1960 to 69 in 1962.
  • Most of the agricultural middle schools were closed.
  • This was where  students had studied theChinese language
  • They had studied practical subjects in the morning
  • They worked in the fields in the afternoon
  • Few of the "red & expert" universities survived
  • One exception was the Jiangxi Communist Labour University
  • It continued to serve as a model for work-study & agricultural education.
  • Central authority over education was reasserted
  • The amount of productive work required of staff and students was limited.
  • Significantly, "key point schools were retained
  • They had been introduced at the time of the Great Leap Forward.
  • In them, talented children were taught by selected teachers in a well-equipped environment.

  • In the Great Leap Forward period, political leadership was provided by
  • a) Liu Shaoqi, supported by Deng Xiaoping
  • b) the economist Chen Yuh (the general secretary of the CCP)
  • c) Peng Zhen, the mayor of Beijing.

  • Mao Zedong had largely withdrawn from the day-to-day management of affairs.
  • His views were represented by
  • a) his wife, Jiang Qing, who was active in the field of cultural affairs.
  • b)  Lin Biao, the minister of defence.

  • Zhou Enlai, the premier, remained uncommitted to either side. 

  • The nature of the contest between these two groupings had been interpreted in a few ways.
  • One is to regard it as a power struggle between Mao Zedong and his critics.
  • It was only after the disaster of the Great Leap Forward that Mao found himself excluded from political power.
  • Subsequent events were as follows
  • a)  the Socialist Education movement.
  • b) the promotion of Mao's personality cult.
  • c) Lin Biao's reforms of the People's Liberation Army.
  • d) the Cultural Revolution.
  • These may all be taken as an assault on Mao's  political rivals, Liu Shaoqi & Deng Xiaoping.
  • Mao's relationship with theCCP had altered dramatically since 1949.
  • At that time Mao's authority and ideological leadership had been unchallenged.
  • In 1956 at the Eight Party Congress, the Party's constittuion was revised.
  • It did this by deleting reference to Mao Zedong's thought.
  • his thoughts had been part of the CCP's guiding ideology.
  • It became easier for white-collar workers to become members of the Party.
  • The Politburo was enlarged and important positions were filled by technocrats.
  • It was recognized that the government was becoming more bureaucratic.
  • It was also increasingly divorced from the masses.
  • A campaign for Party rectification was launched.
  • The changes it brought about did not satisfy Mao.
  • Hostility towards the Party was noticed.
  • This was in his speech "On the Correct Handling of Contradictons Among the People."
  • He gave this speech in Feb. 1957.
  • Among the contradictions he identified was one between the leadership and the masses.
  • At the time he described it as a non-antagonistic contradiction.
  • His hostility increased markedly during this period of recovery after the Great Leap Forward.

  • At the 7000 cadres' conference in 1962, he made an outspoken attack on Party bureaucrats.
  • He accused them being arrogant.By now he concluded the relationship between the Party and the masses was problematic.t
  • He called it an antagonistic contradiction.
  • For him theParty represented privileged power-holders.
  • Since a contradiction could not be resolved there was online answer.
  • The Party would have to be destroyed.

  • Mao had to persuade many Party  leaders to support the launching of the GLF.
  • In 1962the disaster became apparent.
  • This is when Deng Xiaoping openly criticized the communes.
  • He also criticized socialist relations of production.
  • He also hinted at the abandonment of collective farming.

  • He spoke at a Communist youth League conference.
  • He said he favoured any form of production which restored & increased  agricultural output.
  • He quoted a Sichuan proverb: "Yellow or white, a cat that catches mice is good cat."
  • This and other causes of dispute earned Deng Xiaoping & Liu Zhaoqi condemnation.
  • They were condemned as "capitalist roaders."
  • It led to their being accused of following the revisionist course.
  • This revisionist course had been set by Krushchev in the Soviet Union.

  • Mao Zedong's loss of confidence in the Party audits leaders let him to look elsewhere.
  • He looked to the next generation in his search for revolutionary successors.

  • The first rounds of the struggle were fought in the context of the socialist Education movement.
  • This was launched in 1963.
  • Mao shared common ground with other Party leaders in one thing.
  • It was in believing that apathy & corruption was widespread.
  • This was among Party cadres in the countryside where it was widespread.
  • Mao drafted a document, later known as the "Former Ten Points."
  • Poor and lower  middle peasant associations were given a particular job.
  • This was of investigating cadre corruption & restoring the collective principle in farming.
  • This was for investigating  cadre corruption and restoring the collective principle in farming.
  • In Sept. Deng Xiaoping himself issued a document.
  • I t later known as the "Later Ten Points."
  • He supported many pf the  anxieties voiced in th previous document.
  • But he called for the formation of urban-based work teams to carry out the rectification.

  • In the winter of 1963-4 Wang Guangmei, Liu Shaqi's wife undertook a mission.
  • She spent 6 months incognito investigating examples of cadre abuse.

  • In sept. of the next year Liu Shaoqi used information gathered by his wife.
  • He produced a third document, the "Revised Later Ten Points."
  • This document  painted a gloomy picture of the situation.
  • It proposed that
  • a) late work teams should visit selected communes.
  • b) investigate them thoroughly,
  • c) deal severely with cases of cadre corruption.

  • The dispute separating Mao and Liu Shaoqi was now becoming clear.
  • Liu regarded the central issue to be cadre corruption.
  • The appropriate action to the reimposition of Party authority
  • For Mao the issue was the revisionism which had appeared at all levels of the Party.

  • In January  1965, Mao convened conference.
  • He issued another document called "Twenty-three Articles."
  • He made it clear that the target of the campaign was not the corruption of the local cadres.
  • In fact, it was the actions of people holding positions of authority in the Party
  • They were the ones who were taking the capitalist road - they would be the target.

  • In the meantime other controversies had arisen.
  • These controversies  widened the gap between Mao and his critics.
  • Mao had long favoured the use of revolutionary models.
  • In 1964 he promoted Dazhai Brigade in Shanxi as a model.
  • This was because its peasants had transformed the barren land & raised its yields five-fold.
  • This was through their self-reliance and commitment to collective farming.

  • The slogan coined was "in agriculture learn from Dazhai."
  • Other brigades were called upon to emulate their selfless commitment.
  • They were called to adopt their work-point system.
  • This work-point system rewarded political awareness as well as physical efforts.
  • Later that year a work team investigated Dazhai.
  • They concluded that the production figures had been greatly exaggerated.
  • Yet Mao's  influence protected the reputation of their brigade.
  • The brigade continued to serve as a model until Mao's death.
  •  Mao had greater success in mobilizing support in the People's Liberation Army.
  • Peng Dehuai had been appointed Minister of Defence after the Korean War.
  • He had introduced a series of reforms intended to turn the army into a professional force.

  • He was replaced by Lin Biao in 1959.
  • Lin Biao continued the modernization  programme.
  • In October 1962 the border dispute between India & China turned into a war.
  • This was when the People's Liberation Army achieved a rapid & overwhelming victory.

  • Lin Biao had also supported the nuclear programme 
  • This had resulted in China detonating an atomic device in Oct. 1964.
  • But Lin was also politically ambitious.
  • He was determined to make the armed forces an example of revolutionary zeal.
  • He promoted the case of the model soldier Lei Feng who had died in 1962 at these of 20.
  • The soldier died when tying to help a comrade.

  • In 1964 the army's political department produced a version of a compilation of words. 
  • This was to become the Quotations from Chairman Mao Zedong.
  • In return for his support Mao endorsed a campaign based on a slogan.
  • His slogan stated - "Learn from the People's Liberation Army."
  • In 1965 Lin presented an article entitled "Long live th eVictory of the People's War."
  • He anticipated a confrontation between the United States and national liberation movements.
  • He praised Mao Zedong for his leadership in the war of resistance against Japan.
  • He described it as a genuine "people's war" - there was a reason for this.
  • It was because it was a war in which the Party had relied on the masses, not on machines.
  • Two issues were important preceding the launch of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution.
  • These issues were to be central to the movement.
  • The first issue was education with particular reference to access and opportunity.
  • In the aftermath of the Great Leap Forward, emphasis was placed
  • a) one educational standards
  • b) on the use of examinations.
  • By the early 1960s the educational system was more elitist than it had been a decade earlier.
  • Mao gave a speech at the  Tenth Plenum of the eight Central Committee in Sept. 1962.
  • Mao had warned "never forget the class struggle."
  • At the time of the Great  Leap Forward it had been forgotten.
  • A two-track educational system had been established.
  • It worked to the advantage of urban children.
  • This was especially the children of the Party cadres.
  • Mao criticized these developments at the Spring Festival Forum of 1964.
  • He argued that
  • a)  the current  period of schooling was too long,
  • b) that too much reliance was placed on examinations.
  • c) that too much deference was paid to teachers.
  • d) that a stronger link should be established between education & production.

  • The second issue was culture.
  • In 1942 Mao dealt with this in his "Talks at the Yan'an Forum on Literature & Art."
  • Mao adargue that the arts should serve the revolution.

  • The arts should do so by endorsing proletariat values.
  • In the early 1960s, a number of novels and plays had appeared.
  • These works contained implicit comments on political issues.
  • The most notorious  example was an opera written by the historian Wu Han.
  • It was entitled Hai Rui Dismissed from Office.
  • Hai Rui, an upright 16th century Ming official, had been dismissed by the emperor.
  • The opera was widely recognized as a criticism of Mao's actions at the time of the Great Leap.
  • This was because he had protested against the confiscation of land from peasants.
  • In response , Mao got his wife Jiang Qing to formulate a policy statement on culture.
  • She teamed up with Kang Sheng, a former member of the Politburo.
  • Kang had specialized in issues relating to revisionism & counter-revolution.
  • She also found allies in the Shanghai Party chief Zhang Chunqiao.
  • She also found an ally in the literary critic Yao Wenyuan.
  • These allies were later to achieve notoriety as members of the "Gang of Four."
  • This political infighting set the stage for the Cultural Revolution.














No comments:

Post a Comment